The Dutch Defence: From The Hague to Leningrad
The Dutch Defence carries the name of the Netherlands, but it came into its own elsewhere. We follow 1...f5 from a chess player in The Hague in 1789 to the chess school of Leningrad.
By ManyChess.org · · 7 min read

At a Dutch club night it happens sooner or later. You play 1.d4 and your opponent replies 1...f5. That is the Dutch Defence, known in Dutch as the Hollandse Verdediging and in French as the Défense hollandaise.
In many languages the name points to the Netherlands, and rightly so. The story begins in The Hague, in the eighteenth century, in a French book by a chess player who lived there.
Even so, the opening grew up mostly elsewhere. English masters made it known, and players from the Soviet Union built a system of their own around it in Leningrad. We follow that route, from The Hague to the Neva.
What is the Dutch Defence and what is the idea behind 1...f5?
The Dutch Defence is a chess opening that begins with 1.d4 f5. Black pushes the f-pawn two squares forward and takes control of the e4 square straight away. White therefore cannot simply build a broad pawn centre with e4.
After 1.d4 d5 Black mirrors White. With 1...f5 Black deliberately chooses a different path, which creates an asymmetrical position. The two sides of the board take on different characters, and that often leads to a real fight.
These are the ideas behind the move.
- The pawn on f5 controls e4 and slows down White's build-up in the centre.
- Black aims for a position full of tension, rather than a calm symmetrical set-up.
- Black gets chances of an attack against the white king, with pieces and pawns on the kingside.
Those chances come at a price. The f-pawn used to stand in front of the black king and is now gone, which makes the e6 square and the diagonals from e8 to h5 and from a2 to g8 more vulnerable.
Play through the moves on the board and look at e4. You can see that the pawn on f5 guards that square, while Black's king has less cover than before. Try a few White moves yourself, for example 2.g3 or 2.e4, and compare the positions.
With a single pawn move Black takes control of e4, and gives away a weak point at the same time.

Why is it called the Dutch Defence, and who was Elias Stein?
The opening is called Dutch because Elias Stein, a chess player who lived and worked in The Hague, discussed 1...f5 in his 1789 book Nouvel essai sur le jeu des échecs. Stein lived from 1748 to 1812. The name refers to the country where he lived and not to any official invention.
That distinction matters. We cannot say who played 1...f5 first. What we do know is that Stein described the move and that the opening stayed linked to that country afterwards.
Why did a chess player in The Hague write in French?
French was the standard international language of chess at the time. Anyone who wanted to be read across Europe wrote in French, even if he lived in The Hague. That is why the source is in French while the name is Dutch.
Stein lived in the time of the Frenchman François-André Danican Philidor. His 1749 book L'analyse du jeu des échecs is regarded as a milestone of chess theory. Stein's book appeared more than forty years later.
The early history runs in three steps.
- In 1749 Philidor's L'analyse du jeu des échecs appears.
- In 1789 Elias Stein publishes his Nouvel essai sur le jeu des échecs, with 1...f5.
- In 1843 Howard Staunton plays 1...f5 in his matches against Pierre Saint-Amant.
How did Staunton and Saint-Amant make the Dutch Defence famous?
Howard Staunton gave 1...f5 a large stage when he played it in 1843 in his matches against the Frenchman Pierre Saint-Amant. Staunton was an English player who was widely regarded in those years as the strongest of his time. His games therefore drew attention, including from players who had never seen Stein's book.
That is how the opening gained publicity outside the Netherlands. Its fame did not come from the Netherlands itself, but from two matches between an Englishman and a Frenchman.
The Staunton Gambit
The Staunton Gambit is the white reply 1.d4 f5 2.e4. A gambit is an opening in which you sacrifice a pawn for faster development and more initiative. The name honours Staunton, who as the strongest player of his time had a great influence on opening theory.
After 2...fxe4 3.Nc3 Nf6 4.Bg5, Black has an extra pawn, but White is ahead in development and puts pressure on the position. Black has to play accurately to keep that pawn.
Play through the moves and look at the knight on f6. The white bishop on g5 pins the knight, because it stands in front of the queen on d8. Black is a pawn up, but White is more active.
What are the Stonewall, the Ilyin-Zhenevsky and the Leningrad Variation?
These are the three best known set-ups after 1.d4 f5, each with its own pawn structure and its own plan. The table puts them side by side.
| Variation | Characteristic | Black's plan |
|---|---|---|
| Stonewall | Pawns on c6, d5, e6 and f5 | A wall of pawns and a strong knight on e4 |
| Ilyin-Zhenevsky | Pawns on e6 and d6, queen to e8 | A flexible build-up with pressure on the kingside |
| Leningrad Variation | Pawn on g6 and bishop on g7 | A fianchetto, so a bishop on the long diagonal |
The Stonewall
The Stonewall takes its name from the pawns on c6, d5, e6 and f5, which together form a wall. Black gets a solid outpost on e4, where a knight feels at home. The price is a light-squared bishop that has little to do behind its own pawns, and a weak square on e5.
The Ilyin-Zhenevsky
The Ilyin-Zhenevsky is named after the Soviet player Alexander Ilyin-Zhenevsky, whose name is also written Ilyin-Genevsky. It is one man with a double-barrelled name. Black places pawns on e6 and d6, often plays the queen to e8 and keeps as many options open as possible.
The Leningrad Variation
In the Leningrad Variation Black plays ...g6 and puts the bishop on g7. Such a set-up is called a fianchetto, an Italian word meaning 'flank'. The bishop then looks along the long diagonal towards White's centre.
The variation is named after the chess school of Leningrad, now Saint Petersburg. Players there worked out this set-up in the twentieth century. Mikhail Botvinnik also played the Dutch Defence.
On the board you see a well known main line. The bishop on g7 turns towards the centre, the queen on e8 prepares an attack on the kingside and the pawn on f5 keeps e4 under control. Notice also the white bishop on g2, which eyes the same long diagonal.
The name is Dutch, but the theory grew up mostly in England and the Soviet Union.
Why do players still choose the Dutch Defence, and what are the risks?
Players choose the Dutch Defence mainly as a winning attempt with Black against 1.d4. The opening gives unbalanced positions rather than a quiet build-up in which a draw is soon in sight. Anyone who wants to win with Black will find tension here.
These are the reasons players mention most often.
- Black decides the character of the game straight away, because the position is not symmetrical.
- The opening offers real chances of an attack against the white king.
- There are several set-ups, so you can choose what suits your style.
On the other hand, 1...f5 weakens Black's king position. The risks are easy to name.
- The e6 square and the diagonals towards e8 and g8 can become a target.
- The Staunton Gambit demands knowledge from Black, otherwise things quickly go wrong.
- Black has fewer pawns in the centre, so White can put pressure on with piece play.
An opening with weak points is not a bad opening, as long as you know them. If you understand the ideas, you play them with confidence. If you only memorise moves, you run into surprises.
What can you do with the Dutch Defence at the board?
You can try it with Black if you want an unbalanced game against 1.d4. First choose one set-up, the Stonewall or the Leningrad Variation, and learn the plans behind it. That works better than memorising a long string of moves.
As White you do not need to fear 1...f5. You have several workable choices.
- 2.e4, the Staunton Gambit, for those who want to sacrifice a pawn for the initiative.
- 2.g3, a quiet plan with a bishop on the long diagonal.
- 2.Nc3, a natural developing move that keeps all the options open.
This helps at the board.
- In every position, watch the e4 square and the diagonals towards the black king.
- Get to know the Staunton Gambit, as White and as Black.
- Play through the Leningrad set-up on the board above a few times, so that you recognise the plans.
An opening with an origin in The Hague, a breakthrough in England and a Russian elaboration has plenty to tell. You notice it at the board the moment the f-pawn steps forward two squares.
Frequently asked questions
Why is it called the Dutch Defence?
The opening is named after the country of Elias Stein, an Alsace born chess player in The Hague who discussed 1...f5 in 1789 in his book Nouvel essai sur le jeu des échecs. So the name does not say that Stein invented the move, but that he described it.
Who was Elias Stein?
Elias Stein (1748 to 1812) was a chess player and writer, born in Alsace, who lived and worked in The Hague. He wrote in French, the international language of chess in his day, and lived in the time of Philidor.
What is the Staunton Gambit?
The Staunton Gambit is the white reply 1.d4 f5 2.e4. White offers a pawn for better development and more initiative. The name refers to Howard Staunton, the English player who made the Dutch Defence known in 1843 by playing 1...f5.
What is the difference between the Stonewall and the Leningrad Variation?
In the Stonewall, Black's pawns stand on c6, d5, e6 and f5, and Black wants to place a knight on e4. In the Leningrad Variation Black plays ...g6 and ...Bg7 and uses the long diagonal for the bishop.
Is the Dutch Defence a good opening for beginners?
It can be played well if you understand the plans, but Black's king position is vulnerable. First choose one set-up and get to know the Staunton Gambit, and you will run fewer risks.
Sources
- Nouvel essai sur le jeu des échecs, Elias Stein
- L'analyse du jeu des échecs, François-André Danican Philidor
- The Oxford Companion to Chess, David Hooper en Kenneth Whyld
About ManyChess.org
ManyChess.org is an online chess club for every level. Play live or by correspondence, against club mates or the computer, join tournaments and the interclub competition, and improve with puzzles and the chess trainer.
